Get the cuties, you wont regret it!
I'm between a 7.5-8 size in shoes but I went with the 8 because the other review I read mentioned shes between 8.5-9 and there wasn't any 8.5 in stock so she went with the 9. I did the same, the 8 was perfect, I'm glad I didn't pick the 7.5- the toe peek ratio is perfect. I'm 155 lbs, 5'6 so on the wider side toe area with narrow foot, & a hammer toe. It's perfect for my toe, enough room for it to do its hammering. I feel like the wizard of oz lady with my red shoes & they click, clack, perfectly and they are super girly like me! Love the red poppy!